✨ Shield now has support for Avalonia UI

Const vs Readonly in C#: Differences, Pros & Cons

May 5, 2021 | .NET, C#

When working with variables and fields in C# applications, you’ll often encounter the decision between using const and readonly. Both may seem similar at first glance, but they have subtle differences that can significantly impact your code. Let’s dive into a detailed comparison of const vs readonly in C# and learn how to make the best choice for your projects.

Introduction to Const and Readonly in C#

Before we delve into their differences and proper usage, let’s gain a basic understanding of const and readonly in C#.

Basics of Const in C#

const, short for “constant”, is a keyword in C# that is used to declare unchangeable compile-time constants. Typically, these are simple values such as numbers or strings, and their values cannot be modified after declaration. Here’s an example:

public class MyClass
{
    public const int myConst = 42; // Declare a const int with value 42
}

Basics of Readonly in C#

On the other hand, readonly is another keyword that denotes a runtime constant or an object that cannot be modified after it has been initialized. Unlike const, readonly variables can be assigned at runtime, such as in a constructor. Here’s an example:

public class MyClass
{
    public readonly int myReadonly;

    public MyClass(int value)
    {
        myReadonly = value; // Assign value to the readonly variable
    }
}

Now that we have the fundamentals down, let’s delve into the key differences between const and readonly in C#.

Differences Between Const and Readonly

In this section, we’ll discuss the main differences between const vs readonly in C#, including initialization and assignment, scope and access modifiers, memory allocation, and performance considerations.

Initialization and Assignment

One of the essential differences is that const values are assigned during compilation, while readonly ones are usually assigned during runtime. Let’s take a look at some examples.

public const string myConstString = "Hello, world!"; // Valid
public readonly string myReadonlyString = "Hello, world!"; // Valid

public const int myConstInt = Add(3, 4); // Invalid
public readonly int myReadonlyInt = Add(3, 4); // Valid

In this code snippet, we see that const variables must be initialized with a literal or a constant expression. However, readonly variables can be assigned using either a literal or method call, just as long as the assignment occurs during declaration or in a constructor.

Scope and Access Modifiers

Another notable difference is that const variables must always be implicitly static and can only be declared with basic types, while readonly variables can be both instance and static, as well as reference types.

For example, you can’t declare a private const variable, while you can have private readonly variables:

private const int myPrivateConst = 42; // Invalid
private readonly int myPrivateReadonly = 42; // Valid

Memory Allocation

During memory allocation, const variables are stored in metadata, while readonly values are stored in the memory heap. The use of readonly variables also allows for lazy allocation, which can lead to improved performance in C# applications.

Performance Considerations

When deciding between const and readonly values, performance is a critical consideration. Since const values are set at compile time, accessing them is marginally faster. On the other hand, readonly variables are set at runtime and thus have slightly slower access times.

However, the performance difference between const and readonly variables is typically negligible for most situations, so you should prioritize using the appropriate keyword based on other factors like initialization and scoping restrictions.

Advanced Differences Between Const and Readonly

In this section, we’ll dive deeper into differences between const and readonly in C#, with a more comprehensive discussion on initialization, assignment, scoping, access modifiers, memory allocation, performance, and implications in other areas of C# development.

Initialization and Assignment

The primary distinction between const and readonly is in the way they are assigned and initialized. Const values can only be assigned with a compile-time constant expression, while readonly values can be assigned with runtime expressions. Here’s a more advanced example:

public class MyClass
{
    public const double PI = 3.14159265359;
    public readonly DateTime MyBirthDate;

    public MyClass(DateTime birthDate)
    {
        MyBirthDate = birthDate; // Assign a runtime value to a readonly variable
    }

    public const int GetHashCode(string str) // Invalid
    {
        // ... implementation ...
    }

    public static readonly int MyReadonlyInt = GetHashCode("some string"); // Valid
}

In this code snippet, we see that const values can only be set using a constant expression, whereas readonly variables can accept complex expressions, including method calls.

Scope and Access Modifiers – A Deeper Dive

As mentioned earlier, const values are implicitly static, and thus all const fields need to have an associated static context. Readonly values, on the other hand, can be both instance and static. Here’s an example to show how this impacts declaration and usage:

public class MyClass
{
    public const int MyConst = 42;
    public readonly int MyReadonly = 42;
    public static readonly int MyStaticReadonly = 42;
}

public class Test
{
    public void TestMethod()
    {
        int x = MyClass.MyConst; // Accessing const field as a static member
        MyClass instance = new MyClass();
        int y = instance.MyReadonly; // Accessing readonly field as an instance member
        int z = MyClass.MyStaticReadonly; // Accessing static readonly field as a static member
    }
}

Memory Allocation – Digging Deeper

The differences in memory allocation for const and readonly variables have implications on their usage. Since const values are stored in metadata, they are tightly bound to assembly-versioning. Any change in the const value requires recompiling all dependent assemblies. On the other hand, readonly values stored in the heap are better suited for cases where their values are unlikely to change but need the flexibility of runtime updates, like when new assemblies are loaded.

Performance Considerations – A Closer Look

While the performance impact of using const vs readonly is generally negligible, certain scenarios can benefit from understanding how each keyword behaves in terms of performance. For instance, working with a large number of constant values in a project might see the benefits in reduced memory usage and faster access times by using const.

Conversely, if a project makes heavy use of method calls or calculations to initialize fields, readonly might be the better choice due to the greater flexibility it offers in initialization, despite the potentially slower access times. Keep this in mind when optimizing your code.

Implications in Other Areas of C# Development

Beyond the core differences discussed above, const and readonly fields also have implications on other areas of C# development.

Enums

Const values can be used when working with enums, while readonly values cannot. Enums are a collection of named constants, which means they are implicitly treated as const values during declaration.

public enum Colors
{
    Red = 1,
    Green = 2,
    Blue = 3
}

public class MyClass
{
    public const Colors MyColor = Colors.Red; // Valid
    public readonly Colors AnotherColor = Colors.Green; // Invalid
}

Attributes

When using attributes, only const values can be utilized as attribute parameters, while readonly values are not allowed due to the requirement of compile-time constant values for attribute parameters.

public class MyClass
{
    [Obsolete("Use NewMethod", MyClass.MyConst)] // Valid
    [Obsolete("Use NewMethod", MyClass.MyReadonly)] // Invalid
}

By understanding these advanced differences between const vs readonly values in C#, as well as their implications in other aspects of C# development, you’ll be equipped to make well-informed decisions on variable declarations and usage patterns, leading to more efficient and maintainable code.

Practical Applications of Const and Readonly

Now that we’ve explored the main differences between C# const vs readonly, let’s discuss when to use each keyword in practice.

When to Use Const in Your C# Projects

You should use const in the following situations:

  • The value is a simple type like an integer or string literal.
  • You want to set the value at compile time.
  • The value doesn’t change throughout the application’s execution.
  • The value doesn’t rely on runtime calculations or method calls.

When to Use Readonly in Your C# Projects

You should use readonly in these cases:

  • The value can’t be determined at compile time but should not change after initialization.
  • You need instance or reference variables that shouldn’t be altered after assignment.
  • You want to encapsulate your code and use private access on the variable.

Pitfalls of Incorrectly Using Const and Readonly

Here are some potential issues that may arise from incorrectly using const and readonly:

  • Invalid declarations of const values that require runtime evaluation methods.
  • Updates to const values not being propagated across projects or assemblies.
  • Readonly values changing unexpectedly when passed as method arguments.

Const vs Readonly in Specific Scenarios

In this section, we’ll talk about some special cases where choosing between const vs readonly might be more nuanced, such as handling arrays, multi-threading, and inheritance.

Arrays and Collections

When working with arrays and collections, prefer readonly to const. Readonly allows you to maintain a reference to the original array or collection, while const requires a new array or collection to be created every time you want to change the elements.

Multi-threading and Parallelism

In multi-threading scenarios, readonly offers advantages over const as it can provide thread-safe access to values.

private static readonly object myLock = new object(); // Thread-safe

Const and Readonly in Inheritance and Interfaces

Both const and readonly fields cannot be declared within interfaces, but you can use them within derived classes. When dealing with inheritance, you should be cautious when using both keywords, as changes made to a const value in a base class will not be propagated to derived classes. Readonly values, however, can be different for each instance of a derived class.

Frequently Asked Questions about Const vs Readonly in C#

Here, we’ll address some common questions that may arise when working with const and readonly fields in C#.

Can I convert a Readonly value to a Const?

No, you can’t explicitly convert a readonly value to a const. Const variables must be set with a literal or constant expression during compilation, while readonly variables can be assigned during runtime.

Can a Const value be changed through reflection?

No, you cannot change const values using reflection in C#. Const values are embedded into the assembly’s metadata as part of the compile process, and any attempt to modify them using reflection will result in a runtime error.

Is it possible to create a Readonly property?

In C# 6.0 and newer, you can use read-only properties with getter-only auto-properties. This allows you to create a readonly property that cannot be modified after assignment.

public string MyReadonlyProperty { get; }

Conclusion and Best Practices

As we’ve seen, choosing between const vs readonly in C# depends on factors like initialization, scope, and access modifiers.

Summing Up the Differences Between Const and Readonly

  • Const is a compile-time constant, while readonly is a runtime constant.
  • Const values are implicitly static and limited to basic types, while readonly variables can be instance, static, or reference types.
  • Const variables are stored in metadata and readonly variables are stored in the memory heap.

Tips for Using Const and Readonly in C# Effectively

  • Use const when you have simple values that do not change throughout the application’s execution and can be determined at compile time.
  • Use readonly when you need instance, static, or reference variables that should not be altered after initialization.

By understanding and applying these guidelines, you can make informed decisions when choosing between const and readonly in your C# projects. Always consider the best practices and requirements of your application – this will help you write clean, efficient, and maintainable code that takes full advantage of the features provided by C# const and readonly fields.

You May Also Like